Abstract
This PhD portfolio explores the perceptions and experiences of inclusive leadership in for-profit organisations in Ireland and the United Kingdom (UK). The overarching aim is to explore how inclusive leadership is understood and enacted across literature, coaching practice, leadership experience, and organisational contexts. In doing so, the research seeks to advance theoretical, empirical, and applied understandings of inclusive leadership within commercial settings.The project comprises four key portfolio elements.
Conceptual Literature Review (Chapter 2). The literature review synthesised academic perspectives on inclusive leadership in for-profit organisations, analysing 33 peer-reviewed studies from 2009 to August 2021. During this period, research in this context remains limited, fragmented, and conceptually inconsistent, with much of the literature focusing on observable empirical associations while offering comparatively little explanation of the underlying generative mechanisms by which inclusive leadership operates. Existing studies draw on multiple theoretical frameworks and measurement approaches. While this diversity contributes richness, it also produces conceptual ambiguity and methodological inconsistency that obscure the relationship between observed outcomes and the deeper causal processes that may generate them. The literature review identifies a lack of empirically robust, context-sensitive evidence across sectors and geographies, which restricts insight into how inclusive leadership mechanisms are activated, mediated, and constrained within stratified organisational contexts. It also highlights persistent theoretical and methodological gaps with implications for both leadership practice and future scholarship.
Small Scale Research Study 1 (Chapter 3). This study applied reflexive thematic analysis to investigate how leadership coaches in the UK and Ireland conceptualise inclusive leadership. From a critical realist standpoint, the analysis moves beyond participants’ empirical descriptions to consider what these accounts suggest about the underlying structures and generative mechanisms shaping coaching practice in relation to inclusive leadership within this sample. The findings reveal varied interpretations shaped by different psychological and leadership models. These interpretations can be understood as theory-laden constructions that mediate the enactment of inclusive leadership development within open organisational systems. Although participating coaches recognised systemic aspects, their focus was largely on individual development and self-reporting, privileging observable experiences over deeper explanation of how inclusive leadership processes unfold across levels of context. Few engaged directly with inclusive leadership theory or structured frameworks. The study highlights a gap between the conceptual complexity of inclusive leadership and the simplified approaches used in coaching practice as described by participants, indicating limited retroductive engagement with the mechanisms through which coaching generates or constrains inclusive leadership outcomes and suggesting a need for frameworks that better integrate systemic and contextual dimensions.
Larger Research Study (Chapter 4). Using an abbreviated grounded theory approach, this study explored perceived barriers and facilitators of inclusive leadership within for-profit organisations in Ireland and the UK. Drawing on a critical realist orientation, participants’ accounts were treated as empirical descriptions that could inform subsequent explanatory interpretation of the mechanisms and contextual conditions shaping inclusive leadership in practice. The results of this study suggest that behaviour-based models may only capture a part of the phenomenon. Inclusive leadership emerges as a dynamic, multidirectional process shaped by identity, power, context, and perception. A provisional, multi-directional model was developed to illustrate reciprocal influences among individual, organisational, and external factors, highlighting how these influences can operate as either barriers or facilitators depending on their activation within open organisational systems. This model positions inclusive leadership as a psychosocial and contextually embedded process, offering new insights for leadership development, organisational design, and future research.
Small Scale Research Study 2 (Chapter 5). A second reflexive thematic analysis examined how employees in for-profit organisations perceive effective and ineffective inclusive leadership. Participants constructed inclusive leadership less as a set of task-based practices and more as relational experiences of being heard, valued, and supported within psychologically safe environments. These accounts illuminate the experiential domain of inclusion while also pointing to underlying organisational and relational mechanisms that shape how inclusion is recognised and enacted. Participants frequently limited reflexive engagement with their own roles, tending to frame inclusion in abstract and externalised terms that distanced them from personal and collective accountability. Inclusive leadership was rarely articulated in relation to organisational performance, suggesting that it is not yet strategically embedded within many organisational systems. The study highlights the importance of making more explicit connections between inclusive leadership, performance, and shared responsibility, and of examining the mechanisms through which inclusive practices are enabled or constrained in organisational contexts.
Contribution.
This portfolio contributes an explanatory, context-sensitive account of inclusive leadership in Irish and UK for-profit organisations. Grounded in a critical realist orientation, it explores inclusive leadership across observable practices, organisational processes, and underlying structural conditions. Across four interconnected studies, inclusive leadership is conceptualised as emerging from the interaction between individual agency, organisational systems, and external influences. The thesis advances a tentative multidirectional model and a set of context-sensitive capability propositions that explain how inclusive leadership may be enabled or constrained in practice. These contributions are presented as provisional and reflexively situated, offering a framework to inform theory and organisational development while remaining open to further empirical refinement.
| Date of Award | 2026 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
Keywords
- Inclusive leadership
- For-profit organisations
- Ireland
- UK
- Commercial settings
Cite this
- Standard